My True Love Gave to Me…by Stephanie Perkins (editor)

Posted January 22, 2018 by Karen in Books, Reviews /

My True Love Gave to Me…by Stephanie Perkins (editor)My True Love Gave to Me: Twelve Holiday Stories

by: Stephanie Perkins, Holly Black, Ally Carter, Matt de la Pena, Gayle Forman, Jenny Han, David Levithan, Kelly Link, Myra McEntire, Rainbow Rowell, Laini Taylor, Kiersten White
Published by:St. Martin’s Griffen on October 14th 2014
Genres:Anthology, Contemporary
Source: Purchased
Purchase: link link link link link

Rating:One StarOne StarOne StarOne Star

If you love holiday stories, holiday movies, made-for-TV-holiday specials, holiday episodes of your favorite sitcoms and, especially, if you love holiday anthologies, you’re going to fall in love with My True Love Gave To Me: Twelve Holiday Stories by twelve bestselling young adult writers, edited by international bestselling author Stephanie Perkins. Whether you enjoy celebrating Christmas or Hanukkah, Winter Solstice or New Year's there's something here for everyone. So curl up by the fireplace and get cozy. You have twelve reasons this season to stay indoors and fall in love.

I admit that I’m not a big anthology fan. I find the stories in them are hit and miss. ‘My True Love Gave to Me’ was a choice for one of my on-line book clubs. I thought it would help me to get into the holiday spirit and to acquaint me with  some new authors. I’m really late putting up this review but I loved many of the stories and wanted to talk about which ones I loved and which one I didn’t love.


Midnight: Rainbow Rowell

This story features Noël and Mags and their growing relationship every New Years from 2011-2014.  I really liked this one. The premise of just having snippets of a character’s life for several years really made the story enrolling. It was fun piecing together what was going on in the characters life the rest of the year. 4/5 Stars


The Lady and the Fox: Kelly Link

This tells about Miranda’s relationship, over several Christmases, with a strange man who appears and disappears. This one left me really confused. I could not figure out what was going on.  I thought the stranger was a Santa type man but turned out he wasn’t and he seemed really creepy to me. I  didn’t like the magical realism aspect of the story. The only part I liked was the description of the detailing of the fox and lady on the stranger’s coat. 2/5 Stars


Angels in the Snow: Matt De La Pena

Shy (this is the main character’s name) pet sits for his boss during Christmas vacation.  Shy meets one of the neighbors, Haley. I really liked this one. The story-line just rang so true to life to me. Reminded me of the crazy stuff that  goes on at college.5/5 Stars


Polaris is Where You Left Me: Jenny Han

Natty is Santa’s Adopted Daughter. Natty struggles to fit in with the elvis in Santa’s work shop. This was a cute story. Did not blow me away or anything. This read more like a kid’s story to me. 3.5/5 Stars


It’s a Yuletide Miracle, Charlie Brown: Stephanie Perkins

Marigold buys a Christmas tree at a  tree lot near her home. There she meets, North, a worker at the Christmas tree lot. North helps Marigold bring her tree up to her apartment. I really like this one.  I can see something this happening to me.

5/5 Stars


Your Temporary Santa: David Leviathan  A young man dresses up as Santa to surprise his boyfriend’s little sister. I liked the premise of the story. Someone dressing up as Santa to surprise a child makes a sweet story. For some reason the execution just fell flat for me. 3/5


Krampuslauf: Holly Black

A girl decides to throw a New Year’s party at her deceased grandmother’s trailer.

What just happened here? I loved the premise but the magical realism just ruined it for me.



What the Hell Have You Done, Sofie Roth: Gail Forman

A Jewish college student attends  Christmas caroling  and makes a new friend. Cute story. Very romantic and funny. Rings true about how those that don’t celebrate Christmas often feel left out. Not my favorite but loved the characters.  4/5


Beer Buckets and Baby Jesus: Myra McIntire

A Church has to hold their annual Christmas pageant at another venue when their barn burns down. This should have been funny but I just didn’t buy the whole wacky story and the romance seemed really forced. Seemed like a John Green trope. 2.5/5


Welcome to Christmas, CA: Kiersten White

A girl works at a Christmas themed restaurant in a town called Christmas. She is doing her best to get accepted to college and to get out-of-town. Than enter Ben, the new cook at the restaurant.  I loved the story. The characters were very relatable. I live near Christmas, Florida so I totally got the cheesiness  of the restaurant and the town. 5/5


Star of Bethlehem: Ally Carter

A girl exchanges destinations with a desperate girl at an airport .

I really didn’t like the premise. It’s all based on two girls switching flights at the last-minute. This seems really far-fetched in this day and age. Just not for me. 2/5


The Girl Who Woke the Dreamer: Laini Taylor

A fantasy story centered around Neve who is struggling with her bleak life.

Loved the world that was created here. The ending just weird.  3/5

About Rainbow Rowell

Sometimes she writes about adults (Attachments and Landline). Sometimes she writes about teenagers (Eleanor & Park, Fangirl.) Sometimes — actually, a lot of the time — she writes about lovesick vampires and boys with dragon wings. (The Simon Snow series.)

Rainbow wrote her first graphic novel, Pumpkinheads, last fall. And she’s thrilled to be writing Marvel’s monthly Runaways comic, now in its third year.

She lives in Omaha, Nebraska.


About Karen

Karen is a native Orlandoian and still lives there with her family. She loves reading Historical Fiction, Literary Fiction ,’Chick Lit', YA, and Southern Fiction. Some of her favorite things are fuzzy animals, Bigalow tea, and air-conditioning.
FacebookTwitterInstagram Email

Tags: , , , ,